This is actually fairly clever. I am not sure how impactful it will be, but it decidedly sends a message to the authoritarians—yes,I’m aware of the irony, or perhaps the hypocrisy, depending on how you see it—reinforcing Vance’s message to Europe. Whether it changes their behavior much or at all, this drum needs to be beaten until, well, forever.
Certainly sends an authoritarian message to countries that may have different standards for moderation of content. America and our social media companies know best even if we are rare in the Free World to not be members of the International Criminal Court (ICC), established to prosecute individuals for the international crimes of genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression. There's no paragon of virtue quite like a self-defined paragon of virtue.
The problem is that their moderation of content isn’t contained within their borders. The EU has a problem with overreach. I own a business in the USA that advertises online. One advertiser recently asked for my company’s tax ID and bank account information as part of DSA compliance. What for? So they can fine me because they think something in my online ad doesn’t comply with their “online safe spaces” BS and then reach into my account and take the fine? I think not. Too broad and nebulous for my little brain.
Yes, you are right about the overreach. It's called the "Brussels effect": when such a large consumer market as the EU is tighly regulated, the norms imposed tend to difuse globally. And that's the very reason why the Blob has been trying for over 10 years to weaponize the EU regulatory authority to censor speech in the U.S.
Looks like a-holes at both ends. Don't think this take away their visas thing is going to fix anything. That advertiser sounds sketchy, if you ask me, but you didn't. Good luck with overseas business as Trump splashes his mental bath water on everyone's baby.
I think you have the authoritarian action on the wrong end. The action taken by the EU is authoritarian not the response by the State Department. Maybe you should look closer at the repression of free speech in the EU, especially the UK and Germany.
I was on X last evening and voiced my opinion of a certain political hack in the Canadian Liberal Party and immediately a warning outline in red said I could not post that comment by ‘order’ of the Canadian Government. Not sure if I worded that correctly, I was so shocked I could hardly comprehend what had just happened. Going to test it out some more today.
I'd be a lot happier about this if it didn't come with the unspoken deal that they in turn are allowed to censor our own institutions and foreign students here legally on visas on behalf of a foreign nation. If this keeps up, every administration that comes in will have to hand out a new handbook about what is and is not permissible to champion because neither one really wants to give up the weapon of censorship.
Why should students be here on behalf of a foreign nation? If they are students, they should be here to study. If they are here on behalf of a foreign nation, they are not really students.
They are not here on behalf of a foreign nation. They are here to study. That they have opinions on the side should not come as a surprise. This is the excuse I’ve been hearing for awhile. And somehow if they were protesting for Israel, I don’t think their presence would be an issue.
Actually, it is surprising that young people who subscribe to the “Great Satan” theory of America would want to study in what they view as an evil society. Oh, but they want to advocate for changes to improve America and steer it to the correct path? See my previous point.
Okay, let’s cut through this disingenuous BS. These students were basically protesting the university’s investment in Israel because of what is going on in Gaza. They came to the US to pay nearly $100,000 a year in tuition. Yeah, I think they might be entitled to suggest the university not invest the money they’re paying in tuition in a country that is dropping bombs on people like them. You can agree with them or not, but you and the Trump administration and all the Zionists/Israel supporters out there who are blurring the anti-semitism/anti-Israel line are being incredibly dishonest by denying what the issue really was.
And once again, if they were Israeli students over here, I suspect no one would have any problem with them advocating for Israel. In fact one of our big problems is the crowd of people in the US, including dual Israeli-US citizens, who put their allegiance to Israel above the welfare of their fellow US citizens, and I don’t see anyone of your ilk having any problem with that. It’s all good.
So this comes down to viewpoint discrimination, which was what was going on in the last administration, and you all were big mad about it. Where did that go?
"They are not here on behalf of a foreign nation. They are here to study."
How do you know? How do you know that China, Iran, Venezuela, France or any other country didn't recruit and send spies and rabble rousers as students? You don't and I have no doubt it is happening. In fact, it has been shown numerous times that not only has that happened but they have also sent spies to infiltrate fed and state governments. Your supposition that everyone is innocent and just have thoughts is incredibly naïve.
Red herring introduced. Obviously "on behalf of" was not the correct phrase. Such word errors might need to be addressed in the upcoming handbook on what constitutes speech disliked by the reigning administration.
I think I see what you're saying, Lillia. In some sense, the prohibition on antisemitic discrimination (in terms of US domestic university funding) can overlap into suppression of legitimate free speech such as criticism of Israel being labeled as support for Hamas. It's that same slippery slope of "woke" where specifics start to count for everything (e.g. a misplaced pronoun means you're a Nazi). I see nothing wrong with the principle of vetting for real dangers such as violence, but as always it can be so easily abused as we have seen. Definitions become everything.
Lillia, I think you are saying something important here, but am confused by the wording of your first sentence. When you say ..."they in turn..", who is "they"? The EU is already trying to censor Americans both for what they say in Euro countries and for what they say in the U.S., (if I am understanding the situation correctly). Also confusing to me is the phrase "on behalf of a foreign nation." Are you referring to the Trump administration's attempts to deport foreign students who protest Israel's military actions in Palestine?
You have the right “they.” It seems the Trump administration wants an unspoken deal. They will on the one hand fight for free speech (for Americans and in general) and in return we’re supposed to overlook this one little exception.
Thanks for your clarification. I have multiple perspectives on how to combat the violations of free speech in the U.S. Most of these violations are being perpetrated by leftists and Democrats, and there has been little or no free speech or press, or academic freedom on campuses of top rated colleges for more than a decade. It is very difficult to construct strategies to oppose the leftist authoritarianism without engaging in behaviors that are also authoritarian, or could at least be so interpreted. One of the main criticisms I have of free speech activists such as Lukianoff is the absence of any proposals for how we can effectively defend our free speech based government from violent domestic authoritarians, of which the mass leftist movement is the most egregious. The idea that engaging in reasonable debate with adversaries is sufficient to protect free speech appears to me to be untenable at this point, just as reasoning with Nazis, Stalinists, etc. was useless.
The only way I've seen to stop this is to stop the fake media. If not for the fake media lying constantly to support whatever Dems do and say and denigrate whatever Repubs do and say, we would not have to fight authoritarianism. The media is tasked in the constitution, by getting freedoms under the 1A, to hold government...ALL OF GOVERNMENT...accountable. The Dem party is so horrid because the fake media helps them to be so.
The only way I can see to stop the fake media is to make them irrelevant. We can't have a government entity taking them to task, that leads to...well the fake media. The way I see to make them irrelevant is to stop watching, buying subscriptions, listening, reading everything from them. It would be great if some wealthy folks, not Musk, he's done enough, got together and founded an alternative information source with a cadre of great left and right JOURNALISTS in teams challenging each other to dig out all the facts and editors to ensure we see all the facts. Let the full weight of the facts stop the fake media.
I think the answer lies in not allowing the umbrella of free speech protection to be extended into physical acts that interfere with others. Blocking access to buildings, taking over public spaces etc do not become free speech simply by shouting slogans or holding up signs while engaging in this behavior.
Let them publish any vile content they want. Let them try to persuade using only the force of their ideas. But do not give in to the idea that taking over public spaces is free speech. Only people who cannot persuade turn to physical intimidation tactics. No, you cannot stage a “protest” at Union Station. Doing so will result in arrest and prosecution.
I’m sorry if you feel your ideas are not getting enough public attention. Learn to be more persuasive, or get better ideas.
(I figured out how to "collapse" the sub-thread, open it in another window to read. The main thread is much smaller without it. HA!)
I read through this sub-thread, and just have an obvious comment that no one has mentioned.
- None of these "students" are actually what they appear to be, on many levels.
Harvard is part of the "Deep State", that engages in training "students" like the campus protestors. Many of the Universities are as well. The reason they have not been shut down until the Trump administration is that the "Deep State" is paying for these "protests".
Trump is trying to shut down this aspect of the "Deep State" that has been training undercover agents for decades.
I expect the world to settle down now that the money is drying up.
Thank you. I like listening to Tucker when he has a guest that interests me, which is rare. So I don't remember to check his show very often. But Benz is definitely of interest and I might have missed this if you hadn't posted it.
I see this as a win for Michael and all of Public. Some fearless REAL journalism being carried out by REAL journalists. This is what I voted for and this is why I subscribe.
This is great as far as it goes. Now we just need to back off on our own censorship, i.e., deporting various foreign students for their speech, and applying the screws to anyone who dares to stray into anything critical of Israel.
This sounds like a giant win for, well for all of us, but specifically for the efforts of Public and Taibbi and Benz and certainly others I'm unaware of.
Thank you for your work to expose these dangers and for getting them to the attention of our new leadership.
So far, the implementation of these policies and the expression of them and publications (such as the State Dept. publication on Substack) I personally favor. The expressions and policies seem to be straightforward advocacy for the core values of freedom in our Bill of Rights. We will see how this develops. I hope it continues on a reasonable middle path of advocacy.
I see in comments that there is a big confusion between censorship and immigration. Prosecution for free speech is imposing fines or jail time. Denying or cancelling a visa isn't prosecution! Brazil and EU countries can deny entry to every foreigner whose speech they don't like. But they shouldn't be able to tell foreign companies how those operate on their own soil and threaten executives with arrest.
This is a great start. Americans must have their free speech rights protected wherever they are and American companies need assurances that free speech will always prevail. Censorship of American companies by foreign governments ultimately results in censorship of all Americans.
YES! You foreigners attack OUR free speech? Then shove off! You and your censorship are not welcome here!
I voted for this!
This is an attempt to immunize the US against a mind virus. I applaud it but I fear it's a lost cause.
Rubio 2028
Vance Rubio 2029
This is actually fairly clever. I am not sure how impactful it will be, but it decidedly sends a message to the authoritarians—yes,I’m aware of the irony, or perhaps the hypocrisy, depending on how you see it—reinforcing Vance’s message to Europe. Whether it changes their behavior much or at all, this drum needs to be beaten until, well, forever.
Certainly sends an authoritarian message to countries that may have different standards for moderation of content. America and our social media companies know best even if we are rare in the Free World to not be members of the International Criminal Court (ICC), established to prosecute individuals for the international crimes of genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression. There's no paragon of virtue quite like a self-defined paragon of virtue.
The problem is that their moderation of content isn’t contained within their borders. The EU has a problem with overreach. I own a business in the USA that advertises online. One advertiser recently asked for my company’s tax ID and bank account information as part of DSA compliance. What for? So they can fine me because they think something in my online ad doesn’t comply with their “online safe spaces” BS and then reach into my account and take the fine? I think not. Too broad and nebulous for my little brain.
Yes, you are right about the overreach. It's called the "Brussels effect": when such a large consumer market as the EU is tighly regulated, the norms imposed tend to difuse globally. And that's the very reason why the Blob has been trying for over 10 years to weaponize the EU regulatory authority to censor speech in the U.S.
Looks like a-holes at both ends. Don't think this take away their visas thing is going to fix anything. That advertiser sounds sketchy, if you ask me, but you didn't. Good luck with overseas business as Trump splashes his mental bath water on everyone's baby.
I think you have the authoritarian action on the wrong end. The action taken by the EU is authoritarian not the response by the State Department. Maybe you should look closer at the repression of free speech in the EU, especially the UK and Germany.
You're right. The U.S. should crush the EU in every way possible. That will show them who's boss.
WOW, looks like it's time for your meds.
This is the best policy idea from the department of state in recent history. Thanks to all who had a hand in it Marco
I was on X last evening and voiced my opinion of a certain political hack in the Canadian Liberal Party and immediately a warning outline in red said I could not post that comment by ‘order’ of the Canadian Government. Not sure if I worded that correctly, I was so shocked I could hardly comprehend what had just happened. Going to test it out some more today.
Would you share your handle so we can try re-posting your comment?
Use a VPN
I'd be a lot happier about this if it didn't come with the unspoken deal that they in turn are allowed to censor our own institutions and foreign students here legally on visas on behalf of a foreign nation. If this keeps up, every administration that comes in will have to hand out a new handbook about what is and is not permissible to champion because neither one really wants to give up the weapon of censorship.
Why should students be here on behalf of a foreign nation? If they are students, they should be here to study. If they are here on behalf of a foreign nation, they are not really students.
They are not here on behalf of a foreign nation. They are here to study. That they have opinions on the side should not come as a surprise. This is the excuse I’ve been hearing for awhile. And somehow if they were protesting for Israel, I don’t think their presence would be an issue.
Actually, it is surprising that young people who subscribe to the “Great Satan” theory of America would want to study in what they view as an evil society. Oh, but they want to advocate for changes to improve America and steer it to the correct path? See my previous point.
Okay, let’s cut through this disingenuous BS. These students were basically protesting the university’s investment in Israel because of what is going on in Gaza. They came to the US to pay nearly $100,000 a year in tuition. Yeah, I think they might be entitled to suggest the university not invest the money they’re paying in tuition in a country that is dropping bombs on people like them. You can agree with them or not, but you and the Trump administration and all the Zionists/Israel supporters out there who are blurring the anti-semitism/anti-Israel line are being incredibly dishonest by denying what the issue really was.
And once again, if they were Israeli students over here, I suspect no one would have any problem with them advocating for Israel. In fact one of our big problems is the crowd of people in the US, including dual Israeli-US citizens, who put their allegiance to Israel above the welfare of their fellow US citizens, and I don’t see anyone of your ilk having any problem with that. It’s all good.
So this comes down to viewpoint discrimination, which was what was going on in the last administration, and you all were big mad about it. Where did that go?
"They are not here on behalf of a foreign nation. They are here to study."
How do you know? How do you know that China, Iran, Venezuela, France or any other country didn't recruit and send spies and rabble rousers as students? You don't and I have no doubt it is happening. In fact, it has been shown numerous times that not only has that happened but they have also sent spies to infiltrate fed and state governments. Your supposition that everyone is innocent and just have thoughts is incredibly naïve.
I love how we can attribute the best of motives for one group and the worst of motives to another based on nothing more than identity.
And you want to talk about a foreign government infiltrating our own with people sympathetic to them, let’s discuss Israel, shall we?
Red herring introduced. Obviously "on behalf of" was not the correct phrase. Such word errors might need to be addressed in the upcoming handbook on what constitutes speech disliked by the reigning administration.
I think I see what you're saying, Lillia. In some sense, the prohibition on antisemitic discrimination (in terms of US domestic university funding) can overlap into suppression of legitimate free speech such as criticism of Israel being labeled as support for Hamas. It's that same slippery slope of "woke" where specifics start to count for everything (e.g. a misplaced pronoun means you're a Nazi). I see nothing wrong with the principle of vetting for real dangers such as violence, but as always it can be so easily abused as we have seen. Definitions become everything.
Lillia, I think you are saying something important here, but am confused by the wording of your first sentence. When you say ..."they in turn..", who is "they"? The EU is already trying to censor Americans both for what they say in Euro countries and for what they say in the U.S., (if I am understanding the situation correctly). Also confusing to me is the phrase "on behalf of a foreign nation." Are you referring to the Trump administration's attempts to deport foreign students who protest Israel's military actions in Palestine?
You have the right “they.” It seems the Trump administration wants an unspoken deal. They will on the one hand fight for free speech (for Americans and in general) and in return we’re supposed to overlook this one little exception.
Thanks for your clarification. I have multiple perspectives on how to combat the violations of free speech in the U.S. Most of these violations are being perpetrated by leftists and Democrats, and there has been little or no free speech or press, or academic freedom on campuses of top rated colleges for more than a decade. It is very difficult to construct strategies to oppose the leftist authoritarianism without engaging in behaviors that are also authoritarian, or could at least be so interpreted. One of the main criticisms I have of free speech activists such as Lukianoff is the absence of any proposals for how we can effectively defend our free speech based government from violent domestic authoritarians, of which the mass leftist movement is the most egregious. The idea that engaging in reasonable debate with adversaries is sufficient to protect free speech appears to me to be untenable at this point, just as reasoning with Nazis, Stalinists, etc. was useless.
I don't have the answers to this dilemma.
That’s all very valid and really the best of the arguments. How do you combat authoritarianism without becoming authoritarian? It is a dilemma.
The only way I've seen to stop this is to stop the fake media. If not for the fake media lying constantly to support whatever Dems do and say and denigrate whatever Repubs do and say, we would not have to fight authoritarianism. The media is tasked in the constitution, by getting freedoms under the 1A, to hold government...ALL OF GOVERNMENT...accountable. The Dem party is so horrid because the fake media helps them to be so.
The only way I can see to stop the fake media is to make them irrelevant. We can't have a government entity taking them to task, that leads to...well the fake media. The way I see to make them irrelevant is to stop watching, buying subscriptions, listening, reading everything from them. It would be great if some wealthy folks, not Musk, he's done enough, got together and founded an alternative information source with a cadre of great left and right JOURNALISTS in teams challenging each other to dig out all the facts and editors to ensure we see all the facts. Let the full weight of the facts stop the fake media.
I think the answer lies in not allowing the umbrella of free speech protection to be extended into physical acts that interfere with others. Blocking access to buildings, taking over public spaces etc do not become free speech simply by shouting slogans or holding up signs while engaging in this behavior.
Let them publish any vile content they want. Let them try to persuade using only the force of their ideas. But do not give in to the idea that taking over public spaces is free speech. Only people who cannot persuade turn to physical intimidation tactics. No, you cannot stage a “protest” at Union Station. Doing so will result in arrest and prosecution.
I’m sorry if you feel your ideas are not getting enough public attention. Learn to be more persuasive, or get better ideas.
Exactly.
As an aside:
(I figured out how to "collapse" the sub-thread, open it in another window to read. The main thread is much smaller without it. HA!)
I read through this sub-thread, and just have an obvious comment that no one has mentioned.
- None of these "students" are actually what they appear to be, on many levels.
Harvard is part of the "Deep State", that engages in training "students" like the campus protestors. Many of the Universities are as well. The reason they have not been shut down until the Trump administration is that the "Deep State" is paying for these "protests".
Trump is trying to shut down this aspect of the "Deep State" that has been training undercover agents for decades.
I expect the world to settle down now that the money is drying up.
lol! I know we don’t know one another, but you’d be surprised!
FAFO in action
This is the way! Amazing to see a Secretary of State actually act in a manner that advances American interests.
It's only right.
We created and funded this monster. We need to shut it down before those organizations spill back into the US.
This is the latest Tucker episode:
Mike Benz: The CIA’s Use of NGOs to Coup Foreign Governments, and How They’re Doing It to Trump
https://tuckercarlson.com/tucker-show-mike-benz-3
Thank you. I like listening to Tucker when he has a guest that interests me, which is rare. So I don't remember to check his show very often. But Benz is definitely of interest and I might have missed this if you hadn't posted it.
I see this as a win for Michael and all of Public. Some fearless REAL journalism being carried out by REAL journalists. This is what I voted for and this is why I subscribe.
This is great as far as it goes. Now we just need to back off on our own censorship, i.e., deporting various foreign students for their speech, and applying the screws to anyone who dares to stray into anything critical of Israel.
It is truly amazing that we don't do anything to people protesting America, only Israel.
It’s about time.
This sounds like a giant win for, well for all of us, but specifically for the efforts of Public and Taibbi and Benz and certainly others I'm unaware of.
Thank you for your work to expose these dangers and for getting them to the attention of our new leadership.
So far, the implementation of these policies and the expression of them and publications (such as the State Dept. publication on Substack) I personally favor. The expressions and policies seem to be straightforward advocacy for the core values of freedom in our Bill of Rights. We will see how this develops. I hope it continues on a reasonable middle path of advocacy.
I see in comments that there is a big confusion between censorship and immigration. Prosecution for free speech is imposing fines or jail time. Denying or cancelling a visa isn't prosecution! Brazil and EU countries can deny entry to every foreigner whose speech they don't like. But they shouldn't be able to tell foreign companies how those operate on their own soil and threaten executives with arrest.
This is a great start. Americans must have their free speech rights protected wherever they are and American companies need assurances that free speech will always prevail. Censorship of American companies by foreign governments ultimately results in censorship of all Americans.